Teaching Case Decision Points Build a Strong Dilemma in 7 Steps

Knowledge Blog
An educator considering alternative scenarios while developing teaching case decision points

Teaching case decision points give students a reason to analyse. A company history can be interesting, but students need a consequential choice to weigh evidence, question assumptions and defend a recommendation. The strongest classroom dilemma leaves room for more than one reasonable response while giving learners enough information to choose.

Imagine a fictional training provider deciding whether to accept a large corporate contract. The contract would improve revenue but requires customised delivery during the same period as its established public courses. The provider has limited specialist instructors. That is the beginning of a teaching case, but it is not yet a well-designed decision point.

The following editorial approach turns that situation into a teachable dilemma. It can be adapted to business, public-service and professional education cases.

Contents  Give the decision to someone who can act  •  Put a time boundary around the choice  •  Make the options genuinely different  •  Build a conflict between worthwhile goals  •  Supply evidence that can change the recommendation  •  Decide what uncertainty students should confront  •  End before the choice is resolved  •  Diagnose weak teaching case decision points  •  Write questions that develop the analysis  •  Make the preparation demand proportionate  •  Test the case with two plausible recommendations

Give the decision to someone who can act

Name the protagonist’s role and authority. A programme director may allocate instructors but need board approval to accept a contract above a financial threshold. If the case ends by asking what should the director do, students need to know what the director can actually decide.

Authority creates realistic boundaries. The director might recommend accepting the contract with revised dates, negotiate a smaller scope or decline. They cannot simply hire ten qualified instructors overnight unless the case provides a credible route and resources.

Harvard Business School’s case-method resources explain the wider teaching context. The design choices below focus specifically on building the decision that will carry a classroom discussion.

Put a time boundary around the choice

The corporate client needs a response by Friday because its internal training calendar closes that week. A deadline gives urgency, but it should arise from the setting rather than serve as decorative drama.

Explain what is known by the decision date. Students should not be expected to use the company’s later success or failure to judge what was reasonable beforehand. Keep later outcomes out of the student case unless the teaching design deliberately releases them afterwards.

A useful final sentence might say that the director must recommend a response before the client meeting on Friday morning. That is clearer than asking students generally how the provider should grow.

Make the options genuinely different

Three labels do not necessarily create three alternatives. Accept, accept quickly and accept with confidence are the same direction. Meaningful alternatives change resources, timing, risk, customer commitment or strategic emphasis.

For this case, use four credible possibilities: accept the requested scope, negotiate staged delivery, subcontract part of the work or decline. Each needs a plausible mechanism. Subcontracting is not a free solution if quality assurance takes time or suitable partners are unavailable.

You do not need to list every option in the case narrative. Sometimes students should generate alternatives themselves. As the author, however, you need to know that viable alternatives exist and that the evidence supports discussing them.

The Harvard Kennedy School’s teaching-with-cases guidance is a useful complementary resource for planning the teaching around a dilemma.

Build a conflict between worthwhile goals

A dilemma becomes richer when both sides protect something valuable. The corporate contract supports financial stability and market reputation. Existing public-course commitments protect learner trust and a reliable revenue stream. Instructor workload affects quality and retention.

Avoid making one option obviously unethical or incompetent simply to manufacture a correct answer. If accepting requires knowingly delivering an unsafe or unlawful service, the discussion may be about recognising a clear prohibition rather than weighing a strategic dilemma. That can be a valid learning objective, but it is a different case design.

Here, the central tension is how to pursue growth without weakening delivery commitments. Students need to decide which trade-offs are acceptable and what conditions would make an option defensible.

Supply evidence that can change the recommendation

Use a small number of consequential exhibits. An instructor-capacity table, contribution estimates and client delivery requirements may be enough. An exhibit belongs in the case when students can use it to assess an option.

For illustration, the contract requires 24 instructor-days in a month with only 15 uncommitted days. Existing courses could be rescheduled, but deposits have been paid. A subcontractor can provide six days, subject to preparation and quality checks.

These figures do not identify a single answer. They expose a nine-day capacity gap and show that subcontracting alone does not close it. Students must consider a combination of scope, timing and resource choices. State whether figures are fictional or based on a documented source.

For help with the analytical side, see The Case HQ’s business case-analysis guide. The writing should make that analysis possible without doing it for the learner.

Decide what uncertainty students should confront

Not every unknown is productive. Uncertainty about whether the client will accept staged delivery may be central. Missing basic information about the contract value may prevent students from evaluating the commercial decision at all.

Create a deliberate distinction between evidence provided, reasonable assumptions and information worth requesting. If students can reasonably recommend negotiation before acceptance, the case should allow them to explain what they need to learn and why.

A common writing mistake is to remove so much information that any answer becomes defensible. Another is to supply a complete calculation that points unmistakably to the author’s preferred option. Aim for enough evidence to support challenge, with uncertainty that resembles the professional problem.

End before the choice is resolved

The final paragraph should bring the reader to the decision. It may place the director before a meeting, a message or a resource commitment. Keep the scene concise and avoid telling students how they should feel.

For example: the director reviewed the instructor schedule and the client’s proposed dates. Moving two public courses would release capacity, but customer-service staff had already received questions about previous postponements. At Friday’s meeting, the director needed to propose terms the organisation could deliver.

This ending leaves an actionable problem. It is stronger than saying the provider faced challenges and needed a strategy for future success. The latter opens an unlimited topic rather than a focused decision.

Diagnose weak teaching case decision points

Consider the question: should the training provider use technology to improve efficiency? It offers little context, no specified authority and no competing alternatives. Almost any discussion could fit beneath it.

A more useful question is: should the programme director commit to the corporate contract on the requested dates, and what delivery arrangement would make that commitment credible? Students can now use the capacity exhibit, customer commitments and quality considerations.

The Carnegie Mellon University’s guidance on teaching with case studies provides another perspective on selecting and using cases. When adapting published advice, distinguish the authoring problem from the facilitation choices that follow.

Write questions that develop the analysis

Start with a decision: what should the director propose on Friday? Then ask students to identify the strongest evidence for their recommendation. Follow with the condition most likely to make the recommendation fail.

A capacity question can reveal whether students noticed the nine-day gap. A stakeholder question can examine which costs fall on existing learners. An implementation question can test whether the recommended arrangement is feasible.

Avoid asking ten unrelated textbook questions. The discussion should deepen the same decision through different analytical lenses. If a concept cannot contribute to the choice, it may belong in another teaching activity.

For a broader introduction, The Case HQ’s guide to writing and teaching case studies can help connect the decision point with the wider case design.

Make the preparation demand proportionate

Estimate how long students need to read the narrative, interpret exhibits and prepare a position. A short case with a dense financial exhibit may require more preparation than a longer narrative. Tell students which calculations or decisions to bring to class. Keep optional background separate so the core task remains clear. If an important term is unfamiliar, define it in the case rather than relying on students to guess the industry context.

The author should also check whether the dilemma depends on specialist knowledge outside the course. Add a concise explanation where that knowledge is necessary, while preserving the analytical work students are expected to perform themselves.

Test the case with two plausible recommendations

Before publication, write a short argument for two different options using only the case evidence. For example, one argument may support staged delivery to protect commitments; another may favour a limited subcontracting arrangement with revised scope.

If both arguments require invented facts, add necessary evidence. If only one is remotely credible, decide whether that narrowness serves the learning objective. Ask a colleague to identify the decision, alternatives and constraints without seeing your teaching note.

Then identify what would make a recommendation inadequate: ignoring capacity, assuming subcontractor availability or dismissing paid learners’ commitments without justification. These weaknesses can inform assessment criteria without enforcing one preferred answer.

Educators developing a systematic approach to teaching analytical reasoning can explore the paid Certified Research Methodology Instructor programme. Where AI-supported case preparation forms part of the curriculum, the paid PGCert in AI in Teaching and Learning offers a relevant wider learning route.

A usable teaching dilemma gives students a decision they can own for the duration of the discussion. Give them authority, constraints and evidence, then let their reasoning determine what happens next.

Tags :
Business Education,case writing,teaching dilemmas
Share This :

Responses

error:
The Case HQ Online
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.